Positive Reinforcement VS Punishment Based Training Methods

Positive Reinforcement VS Punishment Based Training Methods

Positive Reinforcement VS Punishment Based Training Methods -Dog training is based on mutual understanding and interaction between trainers and their dogs. Even if we can’t talk to dogs in the same way we talk to other people, we certainly can communicate with our tailed companions.

One of the most effective ways to communicate with dogs is through positive and negative reinforcement. Both of these types are necessary for normalizing behavior and teaching obedience. So, let’s learn more about these two methods.

Here’s a breakdown of your information on positive reinforcement vs. punishment-based training, along with key takeaways and insights for dog owners.

Key Takeaways

  • Positive Reinforcement Builds, Punishment Breaks: Positive methods strengthen desired behaviors and your bond with your dog. Punishment creates fear and confusion.
  • Focus on What You DO Want: Reward the right behaviors, don’t just punish the wrong ones. This gives your dog clear guidance.
  • Timing Matters: Punishment after the fact doesn’t teach your dog anything useful. Rewards in the moment create the connection between action and consequence.
  • Dogs Aren’t People: They learn best through methods that mirror their natural social communication (praise, gentle correction).
  • Humane Training is Effective Training: You don’t need to be cruel to achieve great results.

Positive Reinforcement in Action

You provide clear examples of how it works:

  • Meeting Needs: Dogs are motivated by social interaction (play, petting) and food, making these powerful rewards.
  • Tailored to Your Dog: Find what your dog loves most – enthusiasm matters! A playful dog might respond best to games, while a treat-driven dog finds food irresistible.
  • Positive is Proactive: It’s about preventing unwanted behaviors and rewarding good choices to make training more enjoyable for your dog.

The Problems with Punishment

You outline why punishment-based methods backfire:

  • Creates Fear, Not Understanding: Dogs don’t connect delayed punishment to the action, making them anxious, not obedient.
  • Damages Your Bond: Punishment makes your dog afraid of you, eroding trust.
  • Can Lead to Aggression: A cornered, scared dog may bite out of self-defense.
  • Doesn’t Address Root Causes: Punishment suppresses the behavior but doesn’t address the underlying need or anxiety driving it.

Natural Negative Reinforcement

This is a key point! You can still correct unwanted behaviors in ways dogs understand:

  • Gentle Scruff Shake: Mimics how dogs correct each other, establishing boundaries.
  • Withdrawing Attention: Briefly ignoring a dog demanding attention sends a clear message.

When to Seek Professional Help

While positive methods work for most dogs, there are times a trainer is invaluable:

  • Severe Behavior Problems: A trainer can pinpoint the root cause and offer safe solutions.
  • Your Dog is Fearful or Anxious: Trainers can help build confidence in a positive way.
  • Communication Breakdown: They can act as a translator, helping you and your dog understand each other better.

Let’s Talk About Your Dog! To help you choose the very best training approach, consider:

  • What is your dog’s breed and age? Temperament and learning style vary.
  • Are you trying to correct a specific bad habit, or just starting with general obedience?
  • Have you tried any training methods before? What worked, and what didn’t?

Remember, the best training method is the one that makes both you and your dog happy. With patience, consistency, and a focus on positive reinforcement, you’ll transform your dog into a well-behaved, joyful companion!

What Is Positive Reinforcement Training Techniques:

Positive reinforcement is essential for your dog to understand what kind of behavior you like. Wanting to continue to receive positive reinforcement, the dog will be ready to scold the desired behavior in the future.

Positive reinforcement will be meaningful (interesting, important) for the dog if it satisfies any of its needs. There are two basic needs of dogs that can be used in training – the need for social interaction and the need for nutrition.

The need for social communication and interaction is vital for dogs. Wild canine relatives, such as wolves, marry, play, laze, and eat surrounded by their kind – in their pack.

Our domestic dogs, descendants of wolves, instinctively seek out their pack. Therefore, your dog views people and other dogs in your home in this role.

The trainer can reinforce the desired behavior of his dog using three very effective “social rewards” (three types of positive social reinforcement) – affection, play, and verbal praise.

Dogs love to touch. Gentle stroking behind the ears or vigorous massage of the back and lower back is very enjoyable for most dogs. Receiving such influence after completing the obedience exercise will be considered by the dog as positive reinforcement (reward).

The dog will know that you liked his behavior. But dogs don’t seem to like having their heads pounded on like a drum. And yet, a dog can have its own, unique to it, areas of the body that are sensitive to caresses.

Play is a form of other enjoyable social interaction. Most dogs love to play. Find an object your dog loves, such as a squeaky toy or ball.

Play with your dog after he completes the obedience exercise. When I trained my golden retriever, Woody, in A.K.S. obedience training, I always carried a tennis ball in my jacket pocket.

After a two-minute exercise, I played with Woody with a ball for about two minutes – I threw the ball into the grass, and Woody found it. Woody loved these games and soon realized that the activities ultimately led to fun games.

Your dog also interprets verbal praise (conditioned positive reinforcement) as a reward. Dogs are attracted to enthusiastic, high-pitched sounds.

A dull repetition of “Good dog, good dog” will not be effective as a reinforcer. Be lively. Make praise interesting for your dog. Watch its tail – if it wags, the dog accepts praise. Keep in mind that different dogs have different levels of excitability.

Some of them may enjoy mild praise, while others require more intense stimulation. You must find your verbal praise to keep your dog happy during training.

Nutrition is another basic need of a dog. Food reinforcement is very helpful in learning. Training instructors have varying opinions regarding the use of food reinforcement as a reward.

Some people believe that the presence of food interferes with the dog’s concentration on behavior during training. I don’t agree with this.

After all, the thought of food does not disrupt the wolf’s concentration when he is learning to hunt rabbits. But, on the contrary, it strengthens it.

Other training instructors believe that if food reinforcement is used in training, the dog will only obey when hungry. But I recommend using food as a form of positive reinforcement. If nutritional supplements are used correctly, such positive reinforcement will not cause problems in learning.

What Is Punishment-based Training Methods?

Love, praise, and reward are very important aspects of successful dog training. But, unfortunately, this is not enough.

Negative reinforcement is also necessary if the trainer wants to succeed in communicating with his dog if he wants her to fully understand him.

As I mentioned earlier, training should be based on the dog’s attitude and worldview. For example, a wolf maintains order in its pack through demonstrative and physical interaction.

However, the wolf does not punish the members of his pack. Likewise, I recommend that you refrain from punishing your dog.

A dog pack leader does not kick, punch, or kill members of his pack whose behavior he does not like. I strongly recommend that you avoid these abusive methods as well. Instead, use these types of natural negative reinforcement when training your dog.

Dogs also bite each other. You’ve probably observed how a dog defends its bone when another dog tries to take it away. First, the owner’s dog growls. If this does not help, teeth are used.

Another natural negative reinforcement is a push to the nape of the dog’s neck. The scruff is the area of the neck in front of the shoulders.

Neck ruffling is used by dogs to correct the behavior of puppies. I have also observed adult dogs latching onto another dog’s scruff of the neck in an attempt to assert dominance.

If you are not inclined to bite your dog, this is the type of negative reinforcement you can use. Both types of negative reinforcement are understandable to dogs – it’s their language. I strongly advise you to speak to your dog in their language, so he will understand you faster.

Which Technique Is Helpful To Train Dog Behavior?

There is a big difference between punishment and negative reinforcement. Punishment occurs after an individual has committed an undesirable act.

Negative reinforcement occurs during unwanted behavior. In this case, it is easier for the dog to associate unpleasant stimuli with performing the unwanted behavior. As we know, punishment, as retribution for a crime, is inevitable.

Negative reinforcement is always associated in time with behavior. Dogs are not capable of thinking like this: “Yeah, I’m being punished now for what I did two hours earlier!” Therefore, the use of negative reinforcement is most effective in training and correcting behavior.

Dogs find it difficult to understand why they are being punished, and they are prone to misinterpreting their actions.

For instance, it might seem reasonable to put them in their box after they have an accident on the living room carpet and start yelling. But that dog might take those actions as a sign that it’s improper to urinate there, and as a result, they might begin to conceal their accidents in unexpected locations throughout the house.

Positive reinforcement prevents communication problems that are caused by punishment. In this case, it’s right to take them outdoors right away and show them that’s where it’s proper for them to relieve themselves. Reward and commend them when they go outside to relieve themselves.

Additionally dehumanizing your dog, punishment can make them apathetic and uninspired. The greatest way to illustrate positive reinforcement is to use an example from a human-to-human interaction.

Your boss’s physical aggression or ranting when you make a mistake at work degrades you and makes you feel ashamed and unmotivated.

You come away from a more fruitful conversation feeling relieved, appreciative, and inspired since it gets to the core of the issue and offers a way to keep it from happening in the future. Positive and negative reinforcement have the same effects on your dog.


Over time, you will need to train your dog using methods that are not natural. Dogs, of course, do not use collars or leashes. They do not splash each other’s faces with water to train noisy members of the pack to be quiet on command. But if the method is humane, why not use it?

“Understanding the nuances of effective training techniques is essential for any learning process, be it for humans or animals. In the realm of pet care, Dog Training (Course) is particularly vital as it not only shapes obedient behavior but also fosters a bond between the pet and its owner. It offers an extensive course that is cost-effective, with the entire course priced at just the equivalent of what a dog trainer might charge for a single hour ($40 to $120). It covers a wide array of behaviours including Potty Training, Lunging, Jumping, Digging, Whining, Chewing, Excessive Barking, Impulse Control, Hyperactivity, Ignoring Commands, and much more. Plus, they provide a 100% money-back guarantee if you cancel within 60 days, ensuring that your investment is risk-free.”

Aapt Dubey
Aapt Dubey

Aapt Dubey, a devoted canine enthusiast and experienced dog Owner, brings boundless passion to our team. With a heart full of love for our four-legged friends, Aapt is dedicated to sharing insights on dog care, behavior, and training to make every pup's life happier and healthier at ItsAboutDog.com.

Know More

Recommended For You